Our previous post on the topic (you can guess my answer) incited a pretty decent debate, so why not put it in poll format? If you want to see my opinion on it, it's at the link. The issue isn't so big that we should dwell on it, and even though I disagree with the decision, I'm starting to see a bit more sense in it. I still definitely think we should've taken him, but I'll live.
Other than that, get to answering: