Who's to Blame for the Football Debacle?
Mike Wise had an article for the WaPo today on Ralph Friedgen, both foretelling and arguing against his increasingly inevitable firing. While the first page is pretty mild, he makes a few strong attacks on Debbie Yow and Maryland's athletic department feigned as a defense of Friedgen. Don't get me wrong, some of them are legitimate points for Fridge, but some of them aren't. (I wonder if there's any reason it came shortly after Yow burning him on his own radio show). Regardless, the entire thing seems to me very one-sided and misinformed. Like this:
Do you know Friedgen said he used funds not from the athletic department's annual operating budget to fly his team to Wake Forest and North Carolina State this season because of budget cuts?
That plane made a big difference in the outcome of those games, huh? That grand total of about one hour saved (depending on the airline, it could be more or less) in travel time didn't prevent NC's sweep of Maryland. Would a bus have made the offensive line even worse? Would a bus have made Anthony Wiseman even less able to cover Wake's wide receivers?
I'm not saying it's not a nice gesture from Ralph, but I don't see the relevance to coaching.
Do you know his Band-Aid roster, with the youth and injuries people accuse Friedgen of using for alibis, is so banged up that left tackle Bruce Campbell is playing with an ACL injury? Do you know another offensive lineman, Lamar Young, is at this moment a candidate for shoulder surgery?
Yeah, Ralph doesn't have enough depth along the offensive line! There's not enough roster balance and they're too young! Let's get rid of the guy that recruited that thin offensive line and that unbalanced roster!
Oh, wait...
(Continue reading after the poll and the jump. The actual question of the poll comes on the second page).
Or that when classes and practice collide at Maryland, which uses the millions from basketball and football to fund many of its stellar athletic programs, alternatives in times are altogether scarce for student-athletes?
I really don't even understand this one. Is he saying players have to skip class to get to practice, or vice versa? Well, at least he uses facts and examples, so we don't just have to take his word for it.
The idea that the latest "It" coaches in college football would jump at this gig -- say, Cincinnati's Brian Kelly or TCU's Gary Patterson -- is a flat-out fallacy. The same goes for sought-after assistants at USC and Florida.'
Who says that's who Maryland should go after? Kelly's going to ND if it opens up, which it probably will, Patterson's sticking at TCU until a top-level job open ups, and Charlie Strong isn't going anywhere anytime soon unless it's a major job. There's no reason Maryland can't go after Turner Gill, Mike London, Ken Nuimatololo, or (dream) Brian Billick, all of whom would be good hires.
If a big-time MAC coach makes almost $300,000 in a cheap-eats town that doubles as his fiefdom, why would he throw that away for the pressure and pains of this job?
Really? Because, oh, I don't know, he 1) isn't living in friggin' Ohio or Michigan, and 2) he's making literally 5 to 8 times as much money.
Also, Maryland isn't a high-pressure job. It doesn't even come close to the pressure of even the dregs of the Big 12 and SEC. Heck, it's not even high-pressure for ACC standards. If Ralph was at Clemson, he would've already been fired; just ask Tommy Bowden.
And don't come back with, "There's nowhere to go but up." Really? Maryland opens 2010 against Navy in Baltimore. Part of the nonconference schedule also includes an old rival, at West Virginia.
Who used that argument? Of course you can go down, but that doesn't no one should want the job. I think every coach in America would go to Florida if they could, and there's nowhere to go but down there.
If an oily salesman came in tomorrow, it wouldn't change the fact Maryland is consistently out-recruited in its area by Penn State, Virginia Tech and recently Illinois. Rutgers and North Carolina have made inroads lately in the District and Maryland.
Is Wise saying that, no matter what happens, Maryland can't recruit in these areas? So Pete Carroll couldn't steal recruits away from Rutgers in MD and DC? Maybe - just maybe - it's Ralph, and not the area.
But before the people at Maryland make any rash decisions and get rid of a guy who began with three 10-win seasons, they need to know that whomever they bring in will not just be trying to replace Ralph Friedgen; he also has to replace the coach who made football in College Park matter again.
I've never liked this excuse. Ralph did make football matter again, and for that I am grateful. I just have to hope he doesn't bring it down again. Not to mention there was very good football before Ralph, and there will be very good football after Ralph.
Consider that Maryland has never had a 10 loss season. Ever. Maryland is 2-8, with two games left, and both times they will be major underdogs.
Of course, the 12 game season is a recent development, so it's not exactly fair to compare across eras in terms of wins and losses. But Maryland's winning percentage, with a 2-10 season, would be about 16%. That's the lowest winning percentage for Maryland since 1967. That's 42 years. Not even Duffner or Vanderlinden had a season worse than this (or as bad, in terms of winning percentage).
I'm not so stubborn to think that Debbie Yow can't be a little at fault here. No one is so bad that they singlehandedly make a team 2-10. But I can't swallow that she's more at fault than Ralph.
It's the same problem I had with blaming Yow entirely for Maryland's basketball troubles recently. What was the difference between Yow in 07-08 and Yow last year? What was the difference between Morgan St. loss Yow and UNC win Yow? Similarly, if you could tell me how Yow made Maryland lose this year but win the early 2000s, you're better than me.
She doesn't call plays; she doesn't recruit; she doesn't make personnel decisions. She does allocate funds, though, which surely has an impact on recruiting, but I'm not sure how much else. She's to blame, yes, but not nearly so much as Ralph is, and nearly enough to suggest that no one will want the Maryland job.
This is just my opinion, though. How do you see it? Is it the administration? Is it Ralph? Feel free to comment, but remember: I know nothing more than you, and this is just an opinion, on both sides.
PS: I don't mind Mike Wise and this wasn't meant as a hack job. He's a good writer, but it was this just one article I disagree with.
PSS: This isn't meant to be a wholehearted defense of Debbie Yow. I know a lot of people have issues with her budgeting and the Olympic sports - I'm not going to take a stance on any of it because I don't know enough. Money or no money, Ralph just hasn't done his job, as I see it.
0 recs |
8 comments
|
Comments
That article is silly
No one is arguing that Ralph Friedgen is a terrible person – I’m sure he’s a nice guy in person, (and he loves football, so he can’t be all bad) – but that’s kind of irrelevant to the fact that he recruited no linemen, can’t develop a quarterback, and is terrible at playcalling, all of which are more important to coaching than how nice of a person you are.
Isn’t Nick Saban competing for the national title? Isn’t Nick Saban like the world’s largest douchebag? Sure it would be better to win and be nice, but how often is that really an option?
Is Jerry Angelo fired yet?
by ES46NE10 on Nov 15, 2009 5:04 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
Had the same feeling bbroman
I read the article this morning and thought to myself “huh?”
His criticisms of Yow and the athletic department’s support of the program are vague at best. His practice/class time complaint wasn’t very specific and didn’t really tell us how Yow was at fault or how she could change it? Overall, this was more of a rant than an investigative piece and it felt more like Wise was just trying to attack Yow than give us anything concrete. I’m sure Yow does deserve some criticism and I’ve heard grumblings from others that she doesn’t support the two big programs as much as she should. Unfortunately, this piece didn’t do anything to strengthen those claims.
by Ben Goldstein on Nov 15, 2009 6:02 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
Money impacts team performance
My guess is that the big ticket items for any university football program are coaches’ salaries, recruiting, travel, and team meals. Travel and team meals are probably very comparable. The significant differences most likely occur with salaries and recruiting.
Our OL and DL players are too often just overmatched. These are Dave Sollazzo’s players. Dave has been Coordinator since Franklin left in 2005. Ralph knew the organizational skills of Dave when he selected him for the job. Maybe selecting Dave was just a questionable decision by Ralph. However, maybe he didn’t have the money to get another Franklin or Locksley. We don’t know. We don’t know how the football team budget compares with other ACC programs. We do know that recruiting has to improve for this team to compete and we dropped one recruiting area. We also know that we have 27 teams when other universities can’t afford that many and team budgets have been cut. How can Debbie Yow expect the team to improve under these conditions? If the budget is the issue, only she can make the Athletic Department changes needed to improve the football program budget.
by wmterp on Nov 15, 2009 8:02 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
Okay, you guys can hate me for saying this, but...
I would prefer that Testudo Times just not cover football anymore. At all. Unless we’re talking about the promise of Jamarr, Danny, Demetrius et al, I’d prefer to avoid the subject.
There, I said it. I feel much better now :) haha
by kckb8 on Nov 15, 2009 8:27 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
haha
at first I thought it was a criticism.
Actually, I just switched the season to basketball in blog settings.
by Ben Broman on Nov 15, 2009 8:41 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
Haha, no...
Just having a little fun at the expense of our beloved football team.
by kckb8 on Nov 15, 2009 9:45 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
I blame the fact that UMD
is a basketball school in a basketball conference. If they do fire Ralph please don’t do another Vanderlinden and hire someone from the Big Ten.
by ccrun1800 on Nov 15, 2009 9:07 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
Ralph
Vanderlinden left a good stable of players, you see this all the time. In a sense, Ralph won with someone else’s players. He’s on his own now, see the result. We had good years, time for a change. Franklin is supposed to be a good recruiter, well, lets see
by Beco on Nov 22, 2009 10:13 AM EST reply actions 0 recs

by 









